YOUR FAVORITE LOGO TV SHOWS ARE ON PARAMOUNT+

Andy Cohen Names Deformed Celebrities In Billy Eichner's New Game, "'New Year's Eve' Or Deformed?"

Which famous actor was born with a conjoined twin on his shoulder?

Andy Cohen is forced to identify which celebrities he thinks are deformed in the latest wacky game Billy Eichner's cooked up for Billy on the Street.

A little harsh? Yes. But it seems like perfect payback for all the uncomfortable moments Andy's caused with Plead the Fifth, dontcha think?

Related: Sarah Jessica Parker Plays “Santa’s Reindeer Or Sex App” With Billy Eichner

Andy joins Billy in a cemetery in Queens, New York to play "New Year's Eve or Deformed?" As Billy shouts actors' names rapid-fire, it's Andy's mission to determine whether they appeared in Garry Marshall's 2011 film New Year's Eve or if they were born with a deformity.

Seems easy enough but it's actually not. There were, like, 1,000 people in that movie, as Andy points out.

Sarah Jessica Parker, Ludacris, Abigail Breslin, Halle Berry — how many can you guess correctly?

Latest News