Colton Haynes recently celebrated his 26th birthday by drawing with chalk and eating donuts, but the Arrow heartthrob gave us an early birthday present with a soulful cover of Josh Groban's "You Raise Me Up." Boy has some pipes!

Colton recorded the song last year, but just added it to YouTube on Wednesday , and users have been fangirling left and right on his flawless baritone. To wit:

Twerk Master: "Colton Haynes is hot, can sing, can act... Can he fly? Such a perfection to the point where its not fair to other dudes,"

One commenter actually got mad at Haynes for being some awesome:

Steph Cara: "WHAT THE FUCK IS THERE ANYTHING YOU CAN'T DO LIKE SERIOUSLY WHO THE FUCK LOOKS LIKE A GOD, IS FUNNY, NICE, CAN ACT AND CAN SING LIKE WHERE THE FUCK ARE YOUR FLAWS COLTON "

And there was this

Tiffany Vuong: "the amount of girls that will be disappointed when he finally comes out of the closet, myself included... sigh"