Broadway actor Gavin Creel and Grease Live's Aaron Tveit turned up the heat at this year's annual Miscast gala, where actors perform roles they normally would never be cast in.

The fundraiser for MCC Theater saw Tina Fey duetting with Titus Burgess and The Color Purple's Cynthia Erivo singing a showstopper from Yentl.

Creel and Tveit took on the roles of lovers Maureen and Joanne in the song "Take Me or Leave Me" from the musical Rent. Watch the two men get very close during the performance, but be warned—you'll be left wanting more.

Get these two a show together STAT!