Lea Michelle may be Glee‘s loudest, and brassiest, singer, but over the past two season Naya Rivera has proved she can provide a far greater emotional wallop when it comes to her singing than any of her costars. Anyone who doubts that just needs to check out her performance of Adele’s “Someone Like You” last season, the one time someone has managed to do that song any justice.
This season Naya seems to have found her next big song with “Mine,” which she will be singing in this week’s episode “The Break Up.” It has been released early, as most of Glee‘s songs are, and seems sure to top the iTunes charts by the end of the day. You can hear it for yourself above.
The questions is, did Naya sing “Mine” better than the song’s original singer and writer Taylor Swift? Give Taylor’s a listen above and vote for your favorite below.
We think we have to give the edge to Naya.