I figured there was nothing that could steal my attention from last night’s premiere of American Horror Story: Hotel until I came across a single tweet that effectively derailed everything.
— Andy Cohen (@Andy) October 7, 2015
For those not keeping score, Gellar last appeared on Watch What Happens Live in February, 2012 alongside AHS creator Ryan Murphy.
Asked last night if she would consider joining the horror anthology, Gellar left the door open at the possibility coyly teasing, “You never know,” before giving this signature SMG mug.
Of course she was inundated with the now-expected “will there be a Buffy reunion?” question, to which she gave her now-signature response, falsely insinuating that she’s too old now and would need a walker (hilarious, but come on SMG, you haven’t aged a day).
While Gellar was flaw free from start to finish (that side braid!), the real highlight of the night came when Cohen busted out his Selma Blair wig to reenact a scene from SMG’s most iconic film role to date, Cruel Intentions.
Watch the hilarious video below.