While we adore Tyler Posey's exuberance and hot adorability, there is something we need to discuss.

His tattoos.

Tyler's increasing body art has caused a division among his fan base, with some people cheering his ink, and others wanting him to ... think a moment before he enters the parlor.

This weekend is his 23rd birthday, so for this Birthday Battle, we're letting you decide. Do you prefer Tattooed Tyler, or Ink-Free Tyler? Choose wisely!

Let's start with Original Tyler.

(source)

(source)

(source)

(source)

(source)

(source)

(source)

(source)

(source)

(source)

And here's Tattooed Tyler!

(source)

(source)

(source)